[pwh] Kare Kano (His & Her Circumstances) - BD 1080, HEVC, EN subs & dub, OST

Category:
Date:
2020-01-27 12:50 UTC
Submitter:
Seeders:
13
Information:
No information.
Leechers:
6
File size:
15.3 GiB
Completed:
1427
Info hash:
ea171a4a3100a40643e5b0394f04f68c65caeefe
**Kare Kano** has had a hard life; this torrent attempts to bring together all the various options, based around the 20th anniversary BD release. ### Artistic Problems Kare Kano is the last of the iconic animes directed by Hideaki Anno for Gainax. But it is in effect unfinished; Anno lost or stepped back from full control of the project partway through, and the rather disorganised completion that follows doesn't complete the story or resolve character storylines. (He stepped away from Nadia partway through as well, but in that case returned to make a satisfactory completion.) Part of the story may be that the mangaka greatly disliked the treatment of the story, but there are other possibilities too. There is a good account of the problems in this article: https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/feature/2018-12-21/20-years-of-karekano/.141157 ### Technical problems The media for Kare Kano was mostly destroyed, so remastering had little to work with. Gainax's production was also very messy, featuring layers recorded at three different frame rates, and a mix of digital and film editing. The resulting quality is not as good as one would have hoped for, even on DVD. Details of the issues are given and illustrated in these articles: https://forum.blu-ray.com/showpost.php?p=16207750&postcount=3426 http://m1el.github.io/karekano/ ### Version differences The BD version returns (presumably) to the original TV form of the series. Several early episodes have no OP (for some reason the similar source used by [Judgement] has the OP in episode 1 unlike the BD), and the recaps in ep 14 and the first half of ep 15 are silent with a voice-over commentary in places - they also include what appear to be diagrams of viewing figures. The original DVD release added the OP in the episodes where it was missing, and also replaced the recaps in eps 14 & 15 with completely new edits including the original audio instead of the voice-over commentary. The English DVD release (and dub) followed this pattern; it also replaced the previews, which in most episodes had featured the Japanese seiyūs speaking on-camera, with similar footage of the US VAs reading the English previews to camera. For some reason, the later RightStuf/Nozomi release restored the Japanese seiyū footage while including outtakes of the US VA's - go figure! ### This version Whether there will ever be an official English release based on the remastering, I have no idea. Meanwhile, I have tried to assemble the things such a release should contain. #### Video The main series video is taken from the Japanese BDs of the 20th anniversary remastering. The source is 1080; some people will point out that the original material doesn't justify this resolution - however, it is the way the remastering has been presented, and it would be perverse to reduce it to 720, only for it to be increased again for display on most screens. Any extra layer of processing can reduce quality, and in any case, re-encoding at a smaller size saved less space than I expected. #### Japanese Audio Also straight from the BDs. The quality is not stellar, and I decided that flac was a waste of space in this instance. #### English Subtitles Taken from the release by [Judgement], unchanged apart from timing adjustment and tweaks to fit the BD video. #### English Audio The audio was sourced from the RightStuf/Nozomi DVD release. It was edited to retime it to the BD video, and to remove the OP in the episodes that the remastering didn't include it. Unfortunately, this revealed that the DVD remastering was incompetently done, and there were significant multiple glitches in several places in every episode - these were clearly introduced at a late stage in mastering, as they affected the Japanese soundtrack identically. Every glitch was isolated and fixed at the sample level, and this took several times longer than the editing for timing! #### Recaps in Episodes 14 and 15 [Judgement] didn't have subtitles for the voice-over commentaries; however, [Sizumeru-Subs] found a translation online and incorporated it in a revised release which I have used here. There was also never a dub for this speech, so I have used the Japanese audio as the "English" track for those parts, with just the preview in ep 14 and the whole second half of ep 15 using the English soundtrack. The DVD versions of the recaps are included in the BD extras, where I have edited in the English audio and a rip of the DVD subtitles. #### Extras I have included the BD extras (with added sub and dub for the alternate recaps), the extras from the DVDs I have, and the clean EDs from [Judgement]'s release. Also I have included the previews with the video of the US VA's, chopped out from [Exiled-Destiny]'s version. #### Bonus As bonuses, I have included the manga, for those who want the whole story, and the four-disk CD set of the OST.

File list

  • [pwh] Kare Kano - BD 1080, HEVC, EN subs & dub, OST
    • Anime (20th anniversary remaster)
      • Kare Kano s01e01 Her Circumstances .mkv (404.0 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e02 Their Secret .mkv (337.0 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e03 His Circumstances .mkv (352.8 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e04 Her Difficult Problem .mkv (503.7 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e05 Day of Labyrinth .mkv (449.1 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e06 Your Voice That Changes Me .mkv (288.1 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e07 Their Estrangement .mkv (417.4 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e08 Her Day .mkv (442.2 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e09 Atonement for Postponed Debts .mkv (414.2 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e10 Everything Starts Now .mkv (408.3 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e11 At the End of the First Semester .mkv (518.7 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e12 The Location of Happiness .mkv (405.0 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e13 The Subjectivity of Happiness .mkv (399.2 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e14 The Story So Far (recap) .mkv (433.3 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e15 The Story So Far (Part 2) (partly recap) .mkv (515.7 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e16 Eternal Interspersion .mkv (275.4 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e17 His Return .mkv (421.2 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e18 Progress .mkv (340.6 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e19 14 Days i .mkv (586.9 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e20 14 Days ii .mkv (359.6 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e21 14 Days iii .mkv (377.3 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e22 14 Days iv .mkv (399.0 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e23 14 Days v .mkv (355.4 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e24 A Different Story From So Far (recap) .mkv (462.1 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e25 A Different Story From Up to Now (side story) .mkv (372.3 MiB)
      • Kare Kano s01e26 14 Days vi .mkv (412.5 MiB)
    • Extras
      • NC OP & EDs
        • NCED 13.0 .mkv (12.9 MiB)
        • NCED 16.0 .mkv (8.9 MiB)
        • NCED 18.0 .mkv (8.0 MiB)
        • NCED 19.0 .mkv (14.8 MiB)
        • NCED 24.0 .mkv (14.1 MiB)
        • NCED 26.0 .mkv (16.4 MiB)
        • NCED 4.0 .mkv (22.5 MiB)
        • NCED 6.0 .mkv (7.6 MiB)
        • NCED 7.0 .mkv (20.3 MiB)
        • NCED 8.0 .mkv (11.7 MiB)
        • NCOP .mkv (16.7 MiB)
      • Previews with US VAs
        • Ep 01 Preview .mkv (3.2 MiB)
        • Ep 02 Preview.mkv (3.4 MiB)
        • Ep 03 Preview.mkv (4.3 MiB)
        • Ep 04 Preview.mkv (4.5 MiB)
        • Ep 05 Preview.mkv (3.5 MiB)
        • Ep 06 Preview.mkv (3.7 MiB)
        • Ep 07 Preview.mkv (4.3 MiB)
        • Ep 08 Preview.mkv (6.0 MiB)
        • Ep 09 Preview.mkv (4.5 MiB)
        • Ep 10 Preview.mkv (4.3 MiB)
        • Ep 11 Preview.mkv (4.3 MiB)
        • Ep 12 Preview.mkv (5.3 MiB)
        • Ep 13 Preview.mkv (5.5 MiB)
        • Ep 14 Preview.mkv (5.3 MiB)
        • Ep 15 Preview.mkv (4.3 MiB)
        • Ep 16 Preview.mkv (4.1 MiB)
        • Ep 17 Preview.mkv (4.8 MiB)
        • Ep 18 Preview.mkv (4.2 MiB)
        • Ep 19 Preview.mkv (3.6 MiB)
        • Ep 20 Preview.mkv (4.1 MiB)
        • Ep 21 Preview.mkv (3.4 MiB)
      • [BD] Extras
        • Alternate ep 14 recap - Act 14.0, 14.3 .mkv (185.1 MiB)
        • Alternate ep 15 recap - Act 14.6 .mkv (91.0 MiB)
        • Another ED .mkv (16.5 MiB)
        • Burning cels ED .mkv (25.5 MiB)
        • Clean OP .mkv (36.3 MiB)
        • Trailer for BD box .mkv (42.2 MiB)
        • Trailers for VT, LD, DVD & OST .mkv (54.3 MiB)
        • Work in progress 1 .mkv (279.3 MiB)
        • Work in progress 2 .mkv (256.5 MiB)
        • Work in progress 3 .mkv (212.3 MiB)
        • Work in progress 4 .mkv (153.4 MiB)
        • Work in progress 5 .mkv (267.9 MiB)
      • [DVD] Extras
        • EN Preview outtakes.mkv (76.5 MiB)
        • Interviews 1 .mkv (95.1 MiB)
        • Interviews 2 .mkv (107.7 MiB)
        • Interviews 3 .mkv (178.9 MiB)
        • Interviews 4 .mkv (237.9 MiB)
        • Trailer (Rightstuff).mkv (17.5 MiB)
    • Manga
      • Kare Kano Vol.01 .cbz (31.0 MiB)
      • Kare Kano Vol.02 .cbz (31.4 MiB)
      • Kare Kano Vol.03 .cbz (33.4 MiB)
      • Kare Kano Vol.04 .cbz (36.6 MiB)
      • Kare Kano Vol.05 .cbz (36.3 MiB)
      • Kare Kano Vol.06 .cbz (31.6 MiB)
      • Kare Kano Vol.07 .cbz (33.5 MiB)
      • Kare Kano Vol.08 .cbz (21.4 MiB)
      • Kare Kano Vol.09 .cbz (36.6 MiB)
      • Kare Kano Vol.10 .cbz (39.5 MiB)
      • Kare Kano Vol.11 .cbz (73.4 MiB)
      • Kare Kano Vol.12 .cbz (83.3 MiB)
      • Kare Kano Vol.13 .cbz (58.9 MiB)
      • Kare Kano Vol.14 .cbz (67.6 MiB)
      • Kare Kano Vol.15 .cbz (63.0 MiB)
      • Kare Kano Vol.16 .cbz (52.3 MiB)
      • Kare Kano Vol.17 .cbz (52.7 MiB)
      • Kare Kano Vol.18 .cbz (24.1 MiB)
      • Kare Kano Vol.19 .cbz (26.7 MiB)
      • Kare Kano Vol.20 .cbz (24.9 MiB)
      • Kare Kano Vol.21 .cbz (20.6 MiB)
    • OST (1998 CD Box)
      • ACT1
        • 01 - Shiro Sagisu - Abantaitoru.flac (1.0 MiB)
        • 02 - Mai Fukuda - Tenshi no Yubikiri (Full Size).flac (31.9 MiB)
        • 03 - Shiro Sagisu - Koremade no Arasuji (Shoutarou Maachi).flac (15.8 MiB)
        • 04 - Shiro Sagisu - Miyazawa Yukino I (Concerto).flac (20.0 MiB)
        • 05 - Shiro Sagisu - Miyazawa Yukino II (March).flac (20.8 MiB)
        • 06 - Shiro Sagisu - Hibi Heiwa.flac (16.5 MiB)
        • 07 - Shiro Sagisu - Heionbuji.flac (12.2 MiB)
        • 08 - Shiro Sagisu - Sessatakuma.flac (17.2 MiB)
        • 09 - Shiro Sagisu - Tenkataihei.flac (21.3 MiB)
        • 10 - Shiro Sagisu - Eshajouri.flac (14.1 MiB)
        • 11 - Shiro Sagisu - Arima Souichirou II.flac (21.6 MiB)
        • 12 - Shiro Sagisu - Arima Souichirou I.flac (26.2 MiB)
        • 13 - Yosui Inoue - Yume no Nake e II.flac (13.9 MiB)
        • 14 - Shiro Sagisu - Miyazawa-ikka.flac (20.5 MiB)
        • 15 - Shiro Sagisu - Shukakutentou.flac (15.0 MiB)
        • 16 - Shiro Sagisu - Miyazawa Yukino III (Jazz Rock).flac (29.9 MiB)
        • 17 - Shiro Sagisu - Kyousonkyouei.flac (5.4 MiB)
        • 18 - Shiro Sagisu - Miyazawa Yukino IV (Kanon).flac (22.5 MiB)
        • 19 - Shiro Sagisu - Miyazawa Yukino V (Nocturne).flac (12.9 MiB)
        • 20 - Shiro Sagisu - Futoufukutsu.flac (26.3 MiB)
        • 21 - Yosui Inoue - Yume no Naka e III.flac (21.4 MiB)
        • 22 - Shiro Sagisu - Ichigoichie.flac (8.0 MiB)
        • 23 - Atsuko Enomoto & Chihiro Suzuki - Yume no Nake e (Full Size).flac (18.2 MiB)
        • 24 - Shiro Sagisu - Kore Kara no Arasuji.flac (2.0 MiB)
        • Kareshi Kanojo no Jijou ACT 1.0.cue (4.3 KiB)
        • Shiro Sagisu - Kareshi Kanojo no Jijou ACT 1.0.m3u (2.2 KiB)
      • ACT2
        • 01 - Shiro Sagisu - Abantaitoru.flac (875.5 KiB)
        • 02 - Mai Fukuda - Tenshi no Yubikiri (TV Size).flac (10.3 MiB)
        • 03 - Shiro Sagisu - Hachiku no Ikioi.flac (17.6 MiB)
        • 04 - Shiro Sagisu - Shukakutentou (Slow).flac (19.5 MiB)
        • 05 - Shiro Sagisu - Kishokumanmen.flac (30.0 MiB)
        • 06 - Shiro Sagisu - Miyazawa Yukino IV (Piano).flac (12.2 MiB)
        • 07 - Yosui Inoue - Yume no Naka e V (String).flac (15.8 MiB)
        • 08 - Shiro Sagisu - Miyazawa Yukino V (Slow).flac (9.3 MiB)
        • 09 - Shiro Sagisu - Miyazawa Yukino VI.flac (14.3 MiB)
        • 10 - Shiro Sagisu - Anchuumosaku.flac (8.0 MiB)
        • 11 - Yuki Watanabe & Maria Yamamoto - S · O · S (ON AIR VERSION).flac (8.5 MiB)
        • 12 - Shiro Sagisu - Yuuyuukankan.flac (21.6 MiB)
        • 13 - Yosui Inoue - Yume no Naka e I.flac (17.6 MiB)
        • 14 - Shiro Sagisu - Miyazawa Yukino V (Nocturne for Strings).flac (9.5 MiB)
        • 15 - Shiro Sagisu - Uousaou.flac (10.6 MiB)
        • 16 - Shiro Sagisu - Kouunryuusui.flac (20.1 MiB)
        • 17 - Yosui Inoue - Yume no Naka e IV.flac (19.4 MiB)
        • 18 - Shiro Sagisu - Kyoutendouchi.flac (21.4 MiB)
        • 19 - Shiro Sagisu - Kyuutendouchi.flac (14.3 MiB)
        • 20 - Shiro Sagisu - Koeishouzen (Slow, Serene).flac (9.8 MiB)
        • 21 - Kare Kano Cast - Youkai Ningen Bem.flac (3.4 MiB)
        • 22 - Shiro Sagisu - Miyazawa Yukino V (Nocturne for Piano).flac (13.2 MiB)
        • 23 - Shiro Sagisu - Ichigoichie.flac (10.8 MiB)
        • 24 - Shiro Sagisu - Seitenhakujitsu.flac (15.4 MiB)
        • 25 - Atsuko Enomoto & Chihiro Suzuki - Yume no Naka e (TV Size).flac (9.3 MiB)
        • Kareshi Kanojo no Jijou ACT 2.0.cue (4.6 KiB)
        • Shiro Sagisu - Kareshi Kanojo no Jijou ACT 2.0.m3u (2.4 KiB)
      • ACT3
        • 01 - Shiro Sagisu - Miyazawa Ikka (No Chorus).flac (20.1 MiB)
        • 02 - Shiro Sagisu - Ikiyouyou.flac (24.1 MiB)
        • 03 - Shiro Sagisu - Kyoutendouchi (Fast).flac (16.5 MiB)
        • 04 - Alexander Porfiryevich Borodin - Dattanjin no Odori [pf&ST] (arr. Shiro Sagisu).flac (12.6 MiB)
        • 05 - Shiro Sagisu - Tenkataihei (Guitar, Faster Tempo).flac (10.8 MiB)
        • 06 - Shiro Sagisu - Chinshimokkou.flac (19.8 MiB)
        • 07 - Shiro Sagisu - Kinchou Joutai (Piano, High).flac (24.5 MiB)
        • 08 - Shiro Sagisu - Yoin'yojou.flac (14.4 MiB)
        • 09 - Shiro Sagisu - Arima Souichirou I (Piano, Slow).flac (16.8 MiB)
        • 10 - Shiro Sagisu - Miyazawa Yukino V (Serene).flac (14.8 MiB)
        • 11 - Shiro Sagisu - Hibiheiwa (Guitar).flac (13.9 MiB)
        • 12 - Shiro Sagisu - Kouunryuusui (Guitar).flac (13.9 MiB)
        • 13 - Shiro Sagisu - Ishun no Yume.flac (1.5 MiB)
        • 14 - Alexander Porfiryevich Borodin - Dattanjin no Odori.flac (17.7 MiB)
        • 15 - Shiro Sagisu - Anchuumosaku (Slow).flac (10.6 MiB)
        • 16 - Shiro Sagisu - Tenkataihei (Guitar, Normal).flac (11.6 MiB)
        • 17 - Shiro Sagisu - Shukakutentou (Slow, No Chorus).flac (19.8 MiB)
        • 18 - Shiro Sagisu - Kobugekirei [Yakyuu Ouenka].flac (6.5 MiB)
        • 19 - Shiro Sagisu - Futoufukutsu (No Chorus).flac (25.7 MiB)
        • 20 - Hiroo Ariga - Tenshi no Yubikiri [OP-1] (Guitar & Piano).flac (15.0 MiB)
        • 21 - Hiroo Ariga - Tenshi no Yubikiri [OP-2] (Strings).flac (20.5 MiB)
        • 22 - Hiroo Ariga - Tenshi no Yubikiri [OP-4] (Piano & Strings).flac (17.5 MiB)
        • 23 - Atsuko Enomoto - Yume no Naka e (TV size 60 sec Intro Cut Girl's Solo).flac (7.0 MiB)
        • 24 - Atsuko Enomoto & Chihiro Suzuki - Yume no Naka e (TV size 60 sec).flac (7.0 MiB)
        • 25 - Shiro Sagisu - Kore Kara no Arasuji (Long).flac (3.5 MiB)
        • Kareshi Kanojo no Jijou ACT 3.0.cue (5.3 KiB)
        • Shiro Sagisu - Kareshi Kanojo no Jijou ACT 3.0.m3u (2.9 KiB)
      • ACT4
        • 01 - Shiro Sagisu - A-2 (PIANO AND STRINGS).flac (12.3 MiB)
        • 02 - Shiro Sagisu - A-6.flac (20.4 MiB)
        • 03 - Shiro Sagisu - B-5.flac (14.3 MiB)
        • 04 - Shiro Sagisu - B-8.flac (15.7 MiB)
        • 05 - Shiro Sagisu - B-13.flac (18.3 MiB)
        • 06 - Shiro Sagisu - B-16 (SLOW).flac (21.4 MiB)
        • 07 - Shiro Sagisu - B-17 (LONG).flac (11.2 MiB)
        • 08 - Shiro Sagisu - C-3.flac (19.4 MiB)
        • 09 - Shiro Sagisu - C-3 (Guitar).flac (18.1 MiB)
        • 10 - Shiro Sagisu - E-3.flac (8.2 MiB)
        • 11 - Shiro Sagisu - E-4.flac (15.8 MiB)
        • 12 - Shiro Sagisu - F-2.flac (795.5 KiB)
        • 13 - Shiro Sagisu - OP-1 AG,FG & Apf.flac (18.4 MiB)
        • 14 - Shiro Sagisu - OP-3.flac (21.8 MiB)
        • 15 - Shiro Sagisu - Bridge Collection (D-1,2,3,4,5,6,7,9).flac (9.3 MiB)
        • 16 - Narciso Yepes - Mozart no Shudai Ni Yoru Hensoukyoku.flac (35.4 MiB)
        • 17 - Kiyoko Tanaka - Amairo No Kami no Shoujo.flac (11.4 MiB)
        • 18 - Japan Women's Orchestra - Serenade (String Quartet in F Major 3 of 5).flac (16.8 MiB)
        • 19 - Seiko Sumi - Invention No.8.flac (3.2 MiB)
        • 20 - Sofia Philharmonic Orchestra - Dattan-jin no Odori ~ Kageki ''Igor Kou''.flac (53.9 MiB)
        • 21 - Mari Kumamoto - Goldberg Hensoukyoku ''Aria''.flac (15.8 MiB)
        • 22 - Asumi Miwa - Kimi Ga Zutto Hanarenai.flac (23.3 MiB)
        • Kareshi Kanojo no Jijou ACT 4.0.cue (4.0 KiB)
        • Shiro Sagisu - Kareshi Kanojo no Jijou ACT 4.0.m3u (1.9 KiB)
      • Artwork
        • KICA-677~80 (1).jpg (932.6 KiB)
        • KICA-677~80 (10).jpg (400.0 KiB)
        • KICA-677~80 (11).jpg (260.2 KiB)
        • KICA-677~80 (12).jpg (1.0 MiB)
        • KICA-677~80 (13).jpg (1016.8 KiB)
        • KICA-677~80 (14).jpg (880.1 KiB)
        • KICA-677~80 (15).jpg (968.4 KiB)
        • KICA-677~80 (16).jpg (1.3 MiB)
        • KICA-677~80 (17).jpg (1.3 MiB)
        • KICA-677~80 (18).jpg (1.2 MiB)
        • KICA-677~80 (19).jpg (74.9 KiB)
        • KICA-677~80 (2).jpg (498.0 KiB)
        • KICA-677~80 (3).jpg (1.2 MiB)
        • KICA-677~80 (4).jpg (697.9 KiB)
        • KICA-677~80 (5).jpg (956.8 KiB)
        • KICA-677~80 (6).jpg (206.8 KiB)
        • KICA-677~80 (7).jpg (1.1 MiB)
        • KICA-677~80 (8).jpg (240.9 KiB)
        • KICA-677~80 (9).jpg (612.6 KiB)
for fuck's sake anno didn't leave
Nice release, thanks for going through all the work to make it!

nx6

User
There is one thing notably missing here: a songs/signs-only subtitle track for use with the English dub,

pwhodges (uploader)

User
@Roak But from ep 18 he was no longer lead director. More details are given in the article I linked (including the fact that accounts from Gainax employees differ greatly). I've changed my over-simplistic wording, though.

pwhodges (uploader)

User
@nx6 Sorry about that; there were none pre-existing in text form, and I didn't think of extracting them from the ones I used. I might get on and do that, in which case I'd add a link here (no promises though!).
Whoa! You linked to my BD forum post!
You should put the full name (Kareshi Kanojo no Jijou) in the title
sadly this is worse quality than judgment's dvd version i'd stick with the dvd for this
Kareshi Kanojo no Jijou (His and Her Circumstances) [Dual Audio][10bit][BD][1080p][HEVC-x265] should be the titel
@Roak Anno did leave... The evidence is abundant. There's one crazy guy out there who keeps trying to say otherwise (it's probably actually you that I'm talking to), years ago I argued with him over it and basically it came down to him not liking the term "leave", yet he acknowledged that anno stopped working on the show at the point that he 'left'. Since then I've seen someone who types the exact same way pop up here and there saying 'anno didn't leave' etc etc. Some people just can't admit that they're wrong, so much so that they continually spread their opinion as fact despite it going against common knowledge and having no evidence. Please give a source for him not leaving. The burden of proof is on you. All you can do is argue semantics over the term "leave". Move on with your life, dude.

nph

User
The hell? There's people that think Anno didn't quit? It's been common knowledge in Gainax fandom for the last 21 years... I remember learning about it in 99 after hitting up various fansites (including ones run by Japanese people who were close to industry insiders) after noticing his name started being rendered in katakana in the credits (which I knew to be the Japanese version of "Alan Smithee"). Obviously I was confused and by FAR the consensus was that he effectively quit - whether that means he left the production entirely or took on a low-responsibility job is irrelevant. Like @obakechan said it's just semantics. When the director stops being the director, that's quitting the job. I've never seen any insistence otherwise until recently. I've noticed that it's mostly young people trying to claim he never left. Like they don't know what it's like to quit a job or take a reduced job level in protest toward being forced to compromise on your creative or intellectual principles...
Thank you for putting this together. Just reading through the description I can understand the time and effort that it took to make this release.
just got linked this after two years and youre all still wrong lol, maybe listen to someone who actually knows japanese and gives a shit enough to actually read the credits for a show you seem to think you know all about. that ann article is feeding into its own confirmation bias here's an explanation from someone less snarky than i am https://twitter.com/buildknuckle/status/1430548742592159746 shut the fuck up boomers
I wonder how much we actually know of what's going in the anime industry, if this thing is really so different from what we have known for at least 20 years, I'm really skeptical of the news we receive from ANN and other websites.
@Roak is right, everyone else here is a dumbass. There's no argument, it should be public knowledge by now that Anno didn't leave and in fact was working even harder on the series before they ran out of material to adapt, this has been stated in interviews. Also this release is pointless because the BD has objectively worse video than the DVD, let alone Judgment's overhaul of it